Q: Is the Open Matte version in HD? A: Only via the old Bravo HD broadcasts. Most fan rips are 720p or 1080p, but look softer than the Blu-ray because the bitrate is lower.
Q: Does the Criterion Collection include this? A: No. Criterion owns the rights to the Japanese Godzilla films (Showa era). The 1998 film is owned by Warner Bros./Sony.
Q: Why don't they release Open Matte on 4K Blu-ray? A: Directors hate it. Most directors (and cinematographers) view Open Matte as a "TV compromise" that ruins their careful widescreen composition. However, for collectors, it is the opposite—it is the raw truth of the film stock.
Q: Does this make the movie better? A: If you hate the movie, no. If you enjoy the cheesy 90s disaster aesthetic and want to see Matthew Broderick looking sweaty in full-frame glory, yes.
To understand the difference, you need to visualize these two specific moments:
Scene 1: The Manhattan Skyline Reveal
Scene 2: The Helicopter Arrival
The answer depends on your priorities.
If you are a purist who believes in a director’s intended framing, stick with the 2.39:1 Blu-ray. Roland Emmerich framed the movie to hide the seams of the effects and to keep the action horizontal.
However, if you are a film detective, a completionist, or someone who loves the artifact of home media history, the Godzilla 1998 Open Matte is essential viewing. It is a time capsule of 35mm filmmaking. It reminds us that what we see in the theater is not the whole picture—literally. Godzilla 1998 Open Matte
You experience the film differently. You see the puppeteers slightly off screen, the standing room above the actor's heads, and the terrifying scale of the monster scraping the sky.
Whether you love it or hate it, the 1998 American Godzilla endures. And for those in the know, the Open Matte is the only way to watch it.
Search Keywords Used:
Have you seen the Open Matte version? Do you prefer the theatrical crop or the expanded frame? Let us know in the comments below.
The Vertical Kaiju: Unlocking the Godzilla (1998) Open Matte Experience
For years, Roland Emmerich’s Godzilla (1998) has been synonymous with its "Scope" 2.39:1 theatrical presentation. However, a dedicated corner of the kaiju fandom has long sought out a different way to view the TriStar monster: the Open Matte version.
By "opening the matte," viewers see more of the image at the top and bottom of the frame—pixels that were originally hidden behind the black bars of a widescreen display. For a monster as tall as Godzilla, this change in perspective can transform the entire viewing experience. What is "Open Matte"?
Unlike "Pan and Scan"—which crops the sides of a widescreen image to fit a square TV—Open Matte reveals image data captured by the camera but intentionally masked for theaters. Godzilla was filmed using Super 35 (specifically common-top), a process that captures a much taller image than what is eventually shown on a 2.39:1 cinema screen. Why Fandom Prefers the Expanded View
Enhanced Scale: In the theatrical version, Godzilla is often "beheaded" or cut off at the feet in close-ups. The Open Matte version allows the "skyscraper-sized lizard" to take up the full verticality of the screen, making the creature feel more imposing against the New York skyline. Q: Is the Open Matte version in HD
Atmospheric Immersion: The 1998 film is famous for its constant rain and dark, moody lighting. Seeing more of the flooded streets and rainy skies adds to the claustrophobic, urban-warfare atmosphere of the film.
Production Oddities: While providing more visual information, Open Matte versions can occasionally reveal "sins of production," such as boom mics or the edges of sets that were never meant to be seen by the public. Where to Find It
Finding an official "Open Matte" release is rare, as most modern home media—including the 4K Ultra HD Remaster available on Amazon—sticks to the director's intended theatrical aspect ratio. Godzilla movie review & film summary - Roger Ebert
film, often criticized for departing from traditional Toho canon, receives a visual upgrade in open matte format, which reveals more vertical image information and enhances the scale of the creature. While the film remains divisive, open matte versions offer a superior view of the detailed creature design and New York destruction scenes. For a detailed comparison, see the discussion at Godzilla (1998) | The Gigantic Project
, directed by Roland Emmerich, was filmed using the process, which allows for the creation of an "Open Matte" version. Unlike the theatrical release which is cropped for a wide cinematic look, the open matte version reveals more visual information at the top and bottom of the frame. Understanding the Formats Theatrical Version (2.39:1)
: This is the intended "Scope" presentation seen in theaters and on most 4K/Blu-ray releases. It uses "soft matting" to crop the original film image into a thin, wide rectangle for a cinematic feel. Open Matte Version (1.78:1 / 16:9)
: By removing the horizontal mattes (black bars), more of the originally exposed 35mm film is visible. This version fills modern widescreen TVs completely without losing significant detail on the sides. Visual Impact on the Kaiju In a monster movie like
, the aspect ratio significantly affects the sense of scale: Verticality
: Fans often prefer the open matte version because it showcases the full height of Godzilla (Zilla) as he towers over New York City. In scenes where his head or spines might be cut off by theatrical bars, the open matte reveals his entire profile. To understand the difference, you need to visualize
: Comparisons show that while the widescreen version feels more focused and cinematic, the open matte version reveals additional environment details, such as more of the East River or the street-level destruction. Availability and Controversy
Godzilla (1998) open matte version is a unique way to experience Roland Emmerich’s kaiju film, offering a taller frame that reveals visual information usually hidden by theatrical "black bars". What is the Open Matte Version? While the standard theatrical and Blu-ray releases use a 2.39:1 widescreen aspect ratio, the film was shot using
. This technique allows for an "open matte" presentation where the top and bottom of the 35mm frame are "unmasked," filling a 1.78:1 (16:9) 1.33:1 (4:3) screen without losing the sides. More Vertical Detail
: You see more of the Manhattan skyline and Godzilla’s full height in many shots. The "Monster" Scale
: Some fans argue the 1.85:1 or 1.78:1 ratios better suit giant monsters, as the extra vertical space emphasizes their size.
: Open matte versions are often sourced from HDTV broadcasts (like the French channel ) or certain older full-screen DVD/VHS releases. Comparison: Widescreen vs. Open Matte open matte & full screen main thread
The most immediate benefit of the Open Matte transfer is the sheer vertical scale. Godzilla is a creature of immense height, and the extra headroom emphasizes his size against the New York skyline.
In the theatrical widescreen cut, the Chrysler Building scene is claustrophobic and wide. In Open Matte, you see the full verticality of the building and the sheer drop below the characters. It adds a vertigo-inducing quality that the widescreen version lacks. The rain-slicked streets of New York feel taller, the skyscrapers more imposing, and the destruction more chaotic.
Furthermore, the late-90s practical sets and miniatures gain a new lease on life. Often, matte paintings or CGI limitations were hidden in the cropped-out areas. Seeing the "full" frame sometimes reveals imperfections, but it also highlights the immense amount of detail put into the sets that usually ends up on the cutting room floor.
The Open Matte version was created for a pre-widescreen TV era. In the late 1990s, most household televisions were 4:3 square boxes. To avoid the hated "letterbox" black bars, studios would often create Open Matte transfers to fill the entire screen. By 1998, studios had largely moved away from pan-and-scan, so Emmerich’s Godzilla was one of the last major blockbusters to receive a true, physically open-matte transfer for home video.
This is the most fascinating technical aspect. Godzilla (1998) used CGI for the monster. In the theatrical 2.39 version, the visual effects artists rendered Godzilla to fit the wide frame perfectly. In the Open Matte, you sometimes see the "edge" of the CGI work—where the digital monster ends and the blank background begins, or strange scaling issues where the monster looks slightly too small for the frame because he was rendered for a crop.