The Verdict for "Extra Quality": If you have a good media player (like VLC with de-interlacing on "Yadif" or an Nvidia Shield), 1080i is superior for Voyager. It preserves the original broadcast integrity. If you want a "set it and forget it" file, 720p is safer.
We analyzed three versions of Caretaker: a 720p WEB-DL, a 1080i broadcast capture, and a 1080p upscale from the recent fan-remaster project. Here is the breakdown. star trek voyager s01e01 720p or 1080i extra quality
If you want the highest visual fidelity for "Caretaker" (S01E01), here is the ranking: The Verdict for "Extra Quality": If you have